The Most Common Lock Problems and How to Fix Them
Most lock problems come from one of five causes: dirt or old grease in the cylinder, a worn key, a door that has dropped or swollen so the bolt rubs on the strike plate, loose or worn parts inside the lock, or (for smart locks) flat batteries. Many can be fixed at home in a few minutes by cleaning and lubricating the lock with a lock-specific lubricant, adjusting the strike plate or tightening screws. Stop and call a locksmith if a key has snapped inside the lock, the lock turns but the bolt doesn’t move, or forcing it is the only way it works. Forcing a failing lock is how keys snap and how people get locked out.
Below, we go through each problem: what it feels like, why it happens, what you can try and when it’s time for a professional.
Quick diagnosis: what is your lock doing?
Key goes in but won’t turn
Most likely cause: dirty or dry cylinder, worn key, wrong key, or a door that’s misaligned.
Try first: check the door is closed properly, try the spare key, and lubricate.
Key is hard to insert or pull out
Most likely cause: dirt, old oily grease, or a worn or damaged key.
Try first: clean and lubricate the cylinder, and compare against the spare key.
Key turns only part of the way
Most likely cause: the bolt is rubbing on the strike plate, or the door has dropped.
Try first: lift or push the door while turning, and adjust the strike.
Key snapped in the lock
Most likely cause: a worn or cracked key, or forcing a stiff lock.
Try first: don’t push the stub further in. Call a locksmith.
Latch doesn’t catch or door won’t stay shut
Most likely cause: a misaligned strike plate, loose screws, or a worn latch spring.
Try first: tighten screws and adjust the strike plate.
Handle is loose or droops
Most likely cause: loose fixings or a broken spring.
Try first: tighten screws, or replace the spring or handle set.
Smart lock not responding
Most likely cause: flat batteries, or a connection or setting issue.
Try first: replace batteries, and use the backup key or emergency power.
1. The key won’t turn in the lock
This is the most common call we get, and it usually has a simple cause.
Why it happens
- Dirt and old lubricant. Dust and grit build up in the pins. Oily sprays make it worse because they attract more dust and turn gummy over time.
- A worn key. Keys wear down over years of use, especially copies of copies. A worn key may no longer lift the pins to the right height.
- A misaligned door. If the door has dropped on its hinges, or swollen in humid weather, the bolt presses against the strike plate. The key feels stuck even though the lock itself is fine.
- The wrong key. It happens more often than people think, particularly with keys that look alike.
- Worn or broken internal parts. Older locks eventually wear out.
What you can try
- Take the pressure off the bolt. Pull the door firmly towards you, or push it into the frame, then try the key again. If it turns easily, the problem is alignment, not the lock (see problem 3).
- Try the spare key. If the spare works smoothly, your everyday key is worn. Get a new one cut from the original or the spare, not from the worn copy.
- Lubricate the cylinder. Use a lubricant made for locks. Lock maker ASSA ABLOY’s care and maintenance recommendations say key cylinders should be lubricated at least once a year by applying a small amount to the key, then inserting and turning it a few times. Avoid heavy oils and general-purpose sprays, which collect dust.
- Don’t force it. If the key still won’t turn, stop. Forcing it is the most common way keys snap.
When to call a locksmith
Call us if the key won’t turn after lubricating, if it turns but the bolt doesn’t move, or if a new key cut from the original also sticks. That points to worn or broken parts inside the cylinder, which may need repinning or replacing.
2. The key keeps getting stuck
A key that goes in stiffly, or won’t come out without wiggling, is a warning sign. Left alone, it often ends in a snapped key.
Common causes
- Dirt or grit inside the keyway
- A worn, bent or burred key
- A poor-quality key copy cut slightly too deep or with rough edges
- Pins or springs inside the cylinder starting to fail
- Pressure on the bolt from a misaligned door
What to do
- Look at the key. If it’s bent, cracked, shiny and rounded at the tips, or has burrs, replace it.
- Clean and lubricate the cylinder as above.
- Remove the key with the door pushed or pulled to take pressure off the bolt.
- If the key still sticks, have the lock checked before it fails completely.
3. The lock only turns part of the way, or the door won’t latch
If the key turns freely with the door open but stiffly with the door closed, the lock is usually fine. The bolt or latch is catching on the strike plate (the metal plate on the door frame).
Why it happens
- Hinges have loosened, so the door has dropped.
- Timber doors and frames swell in humid weather and shrink in dry weather.
- The house has settled.
- Screws in the strike plate or hinges have worked loose.
What you can try
- Tighten the hinge screws, especially on the top hinge. If a screw spins without gripping, replace it with a longer screw that reaches the frame.
- Find where it rubs. Look for scratch marks on the strike plate. Rubbing lipstick or chalk on the end of the bolt also shows where it hits.
- Adjust the strike plate. For small misalignments, the opening in the strike plate can be filed slightly. For larger ones, the plate needs to be moved.
If the door itself has warped or the frame has moved significantly, a locksmith or carpenter will need to rehang or adjust it.
4. A key has snapped off in the lock
This usually happens when a worn key is forced into a stiff lock.
What to do right now
- Don’t try the other half of the key. It will push the broken piece deeper.
- Don’t put superglue on a stick or key. Glue in the cylinder usually means the whole lock has to be replaced.
- If part of the key is sticking out, you can try to grip it gently with fine needle-nose pliers and pull it straight out. Don’t twist.
- Secure the door. If the door is open and can’t be locked, use another locked door or have someone stay at the property until it’s fixed.
- Call a locksmith. We use dedicated key extractors to remove the broken piece, usually without damaging the lock, and can cut a new key on the spot.
Once the broken piece is out, find out why the key snapped. Usually the key was worn or the lock was stiff. Replacing just the key will often lead to the same problem again.
5. Loose handles, worn latches and broken springs
Handles and latches get more use than any other part of a door.
- Loose handle: tighten the screws on the inside rose or plate. If the screws are hidden, there’s usually a small release clip or grub screw.
- Drooping lever handle: the return spring has weakened or broken. Replacement springs or a new handle set fix this.
- Latch doesn’t spring back: dirt or a worn latch spring. Clean and lubricate first; replace the latch if it continues.
6. Weather, salt air and stiff outdoor locks
Locks on outside doors, gates, garages and pool fences age faster. Near the coast, salt air corrodes metal parts. Dust, heat and rain all take their toll.
- Lubricate outdoor cylinders more often than indoor ones, at least once or twice a year.
- Clean finishes with mild soapy water and rinse, rather than harsh cleaners. ASSA ABLOY advises against abrasive cleaners and against letting cleaning fluids get into the lock or cylinder.
- For pool gates, test the latch regularly. A pool gate latch that doesn’t close and latch properly is a safety issue, not just a maintenance one.
- Consider marine-grade or stainless hardware in coastal suburbs.
7. Smart lock problems, including flat batteries
Smart locks are reliable, but they bring a few new problems.
The batteries died
- Most smart locks warn you when batteries are low, through a light or beep at the lock, a notification in the app, or both. Don’t ignore it.
- Most models have a backup: a key cylinder, or emergency power contacts on the outside (often for a 9V battery or USB cable) that let you wake the lock and enter your code. Check your lock’s manual now, before you need it.
- Change all batteries at once, use the type the manufacturer recommends, and note the date.
The lock won’t respond to the app or keypad
- Check the batteries first, even if the app says they are fine.
- Check your phone’s Bluetooth and the home Wi-Fi or hub if your lock uses one.
- Restart the lock as the manufacturer describes.
- If the motor runs but the bolt doesn’t move, the door may be misaligned. Smart locks are more sensitive to this than manual locks.
You’re locked out with a dead smart lock and no backup
Call a locksmith. We can usually get you in without damaging the door, and help you set up a backup so it doesn’t happen again.
How to prevent lock problems
- Lubricate once a year (twice for outdoor or coastal locks) with a lock-specific lubricant.
- Replace worn keys by cutting from the original, not a worn copy.
- Keep doors aligned. Tighten hinges and strike plates when you first notice a door dragging.
- Don’t force a stiff lock. If it needs force, it needs attention.
- Don’t hang heavy key rings from a key left in the lock. The weight wears the cylinder.
- Replace batteries in smart locks on a schedule.
- Have older locks checked. If a lock is worn, rekeying or replacing it may be better value than repeated repairs. Our guide to rekeying vs replacing locks explains the difference.
When to call a locksmith
- A key has snapped in the lock
- The lock turns but the bolt doesn’t move
- Lubricating and adjusting hasn’t fixed the problem
- You’re locked out, or can’t secure the property
- The lock has been damaged in a break-in or attempted break-in. See the 5 signs your lock has been tampered with.
- You’ve lost keys or don’t know who has copies
The bottom line
Most lock problems give warning signs before they fail: a key that’s harder to turn, a door that needs a push, a latch that doesn’t quite catch. A few minutes of cleaning, lubricating and tightening fixes many of them. When a lock needs force, or a key snaps, stop and call a professional.
A.Abbott Locksmiths repairs, rekeys and replaces residential and commercial locks across Sydney. See our residential locksmith services or, if you’re locked out now, our 24/7 emergency locksmiths. Call 1300 655 787.
Frequently asked questions
Why won’t my key turn in the lock?
The most common causes are dirt or old grease in the cylinder, a worn key, or a door that has dropped so the bolt presses on the strike plate. Try pushing or pulling the door while turning the key, try the spare, and lubricate the cylinder. If it still won’t turn, call a locksmith rather than forcing it.
Can I use WD-40 on a door lock?
It’s better to use a lubricant made for locks. Lock manufacturers recommend lock-specific lubricants applied sparingly. General-purpose oils and sprays can attract dust and make the lock stickier over time.
What should I do if my key snaps in the lock?
Don’t push the other half in or use glue. If a piece is sticking out, try to pull it straight out with fine pliers. Otherwise, call a locksmith to extract it and cut a new key.
How often should locks be serviced?
Lubricate key cylinders at least once a year, and more often for outdoor or coastal locks. Check door alignment and screws at the same time.
What happens if my smart lock battery dies?
Most smart locks give low-battery warnings and have a backup, such as a key cylinder or external emergency power contacts. Check your manual for your model. If you’re locked out without a backup, a locksmith can help.